Cut Line: Good, bad and ugly from an eventful week

By Rex HoggardJanuary 10, 2014, 7:22 pm

The year’s first cut looms today at the Sony Open and 2014’s maiden Cut Line ushers in the season with a breakdown of the good (Zach Johnson), bad (more point races) and ugly (the WGC-Match Play field) from an eventful week.

Made Cut

Zach Attack. Lightly recruited, undersized, largely overlooked – if that sounds like a ready-made feature for the upcoming NFL draft, then you haven’t been paying attention to Zach Johnson the last few years.

At 5-foot-11, 160 pounds, Johnson arrived on the PGA Tour via a path cut through the mini-tours and various secondary circuits and proceeded to outwork his competition, at times to his own detriment.

There was no pedigree and few outside Johnson’s inner circle recognized his true potential, but his victory on Sunday at the Hyundai Tournament of Champions was his second consecutive title, dating to last month’s World Challenge, and his third in his last six starts.

Following his Masters’ victory in 2007, the everyman demurely announced, “I'm Zach Johnson and I'm from Cedar Rapids, Iowa.”

Although he’d never be so boastful, his new calling card is that he is one of just three Tour players to have 10 wins and a major championship, along with Tiger Woods and Phil Mickelson, since 2007.

Refreshing Wie. The question was absurd when considered in context. Essentially, your scribe wanted to ask Michelle Wie in an interview earlier this week if she felt as if she’d under-achieved in her career?

Wie had been atop golf’s radar for more than a decade and yet has just two LPGA victories to show for it. But then you realize she’s just 24. Weren’t we all under-achievers at 24?

Yet when asked if she was where she thought she would be 10 years earlier, Wie’s answer was refreshingly honest.

“No, I am not,” she admitted. “But I wouldn’t trade any of the experiences I’ve had or any of the decisions I made.”

Wie has been an easy target for the better part of a decade and time will tell if she ever lives up to the hype, but in the final analysis it is clear she’s pleased with the person she’s become if not the player everyone thought she would be.

Made Cut-Did Not Finish (MDF)

Point missing. It’s official, all of professional golf has gone point crazy.

At least that’s the immediate takeaway from Wednesday’s news that the LPGA Tour will go to a season-long, points-based system this year (the Race to the CME Globe) similar to what the PGA Tour has used since 2007.

Lost in this rush to mathematical madness is the fact that it was the Champions Tour, with the Charles Schwab Cup, that first waded into the points pool and that the vast majority of golf fans still have little interest in the season-long sprint.

Majors and money earned have always been the benchmark in professional golf, and that’s a point many of the game’s decision makers continue to miss.

Tweet of the week:



The tweet was directed at Vanderbilt head football coach James Franklin, who was being wooed by various NFL and college teams to leave Vandy. Unfortunately for Sneds, it looks like Franklin is headed to Penn State. However, his offer may still be a boon for the Commodores. We hear Steve Spurrier will work for golf lessons.

Missed Cut

Campus visit. It’s impossible to know for sure the details behind Matt Fitzpatrick’s decision to bolt Northwestern University after just one semester, but considering the importance he placed on receiving a quality education, as well as a quality game, during the recruiting process it was a curious move.

“The surprising part for us was how much his family valued education and how important it was to them during the recruitment at Northwestern,” Northwestern golf coach Pat Goss told’s Ryan Lavner. “His family and Matt had nothing but espoused the value of education here.”

Perhaps the reigning U.S. Amateur champion’s decision to return to England and “dedicate 100 percent of my time to the game,” will be the right choice. But given the cautionary tales that litter the golf landscape (see Wie, Michelle above) the move feels reactionary at best and potentially disastrous at worst.

No Match (Play). Be it the unintended consequences of the PGA Tour’s new wraparound season, an embarrassment of playing opportunities for the world’s top players or just a less-than-endearing golf course, this year’s WGC-Accenture Match Play Championship is starting to feel less like “March Madness” than it is a February flop.

Adam Scott, Justin Rose and Phil Mickelson have already announced they do not plan to play the year’s first World Golf Championship, and it appeared that Tiger Woods would likely skip the event to watch his girlfriend, Lindsey Vonn, compete in the Winter Olympics until Vonn withdrew from the Games with an injury.

If Woods plays, and that’s a healthy if, that still means three of the world’s top 5 players are out at the no-cut, big-money event.

Perhaps this is all no more than an imperfect storm, but the truth is Dove Mountain was in a deep freeze with players long before last year’s snow storm halted play. Relocation may not be the tonic to assure the Match Play lands every top player, but it would be a good start.

Getty Images

Montana parents can't watch kids play high school golf

By Grill Room TeamDecember 11, 2017, 9:47 pm

Well, this is a one new one.

According to a report from KTVQ in Montana, this line in the Montana State High School Association rule book all but forbids spectators from observing high school golf in that state:

“No spectators/fans are allowed on the course except for certain locations as designated by the tournament manager and club professional.”

Part of the issue, according to the report, is that most courses don't bother to designate those "certain locations" leaving parents unable to watch their kids compete.

“If you tell a parent that they can’t watch their kid play in the Thanksgiving Day football game, they would riot,” Chris Kelley, a high school golf parent, told KTVQ.

The report lists illegal outside coaching as one of the rule's chief motivations, but Montana State women's golf coach Brittany Basye doesn't quite buy that.

“I can go to a softball game and I can sit right behind the pitcher. I can make hand signals,” she is quoted in the report. “I can yell out names. I can do the same thing on a softball field that might affect that kid. Football games we can yell as loud as we want when someone is making a pass or a catch.”

The MHSA has argued that unlike other sports that are played in a confined area, the sprawling nature of a golf course would make it difficult to hire enough marshals to keep unruly spectators in check.

Meanwhile, there's a lawyer quoted in the report claiming this is some kind of civil rights issue.

Worth note, Montana is one of only two states that doesn't allow spectators on the course. The other state, Alaska, does not offer high school golf.

PGA Tour suspends Hensby for anti-doping violation

By Golf Channel DigitalDecember 11, 2017, 8:02 pm

Mark Hensby has been suspended for one year by the PGA Tour for violating the Tour’s anti-doping policy by failing to provide a sample after notification.

The Tour made the announcement Monday, reporting that Hensby will be eligible to return on Oct. 26, 2018.

The statement reads:

The PGA Tour announced today that Mark Hensby has violated the Tour Anti-Doping Policy for failing to provide a drug testing sample after notification and has been suspended for a period of one year. He will be eligible to return on Oct. 26, 2018.

Hensby, 46, won the John Deere Classic in 2004. He played the Tour this past year, playing just 14 events. He finished 142nd on the money list. He once ranked among the top 30 in the Official World Golf Ranking but ranks No. 1,623 today.

The Sunshine Tour recently suspended player Etienne Bond for one year for failing a drug test. Players previously suspended by the PGA Tour for violating the anti-doping policy include Scott Stallings and Doug Barron.

The PGA Tour implemented revisions to its anti-doping program with the start of the 2017-18 season. The revisions include blood testing and the supplementation of the Tour’s prohibited list to include all of the substances and methods on the World Anti-Doping Agency prohibited list. As part of this season’s revisions, the Tour announced it would also begin reporting suspensions due to recreational drug use.

The Tour said it would not issue further comment on Hensby's suspension.

Good time to hang up on viewer call-ins

By Randall MellDecember 11, 2017, 7:40 pm

Golf announced the most massive layoff in the industry’s history on Monday morning.

Armchair referees around the world were given their pink slips.

It’s a glorious jettisoning of unsolicited help.

Goodbye and good riddance.

The USGA and R&A’s announcement of a new set of protocols Monday will end the practice of viewer call-ins and emails in the reporting of rules infractions.

“What we have heard from players and committees is ‘Let’s leave the rules and administration of the event to the players and those responsible for running the tournament,’” said Thomas Pagel, the USGA’s senior director of rules and amateur status.


The protocols, formed by a working group that included the PGA Tour, LPGA, European Tour, Ladies European Tour and the PGA of America, also establish the use of rules officials to monitor the televised broadcasts of events.

Additionally, the protocols will eliminate the two-shot penalty when a player signs an incorrect scorecard because the player was unaware of a violation.

Yes, I can hear you folks saying armchair rules officials help make sure every meaningful infraction comes to light. I hear you saying they make the game better, more honest, by helping reduce the possibility somebody violates the rules to win.

But at what cost?

The chaos and mayhem armchair referees create can ruin the spirit of fair play every bit as much as an unreported violation. The chaos and mayhem armchair rules officials create can be as much a threat to fair play as the violations themselves.

The Rules of Golf are devised to protect the integrity of the game, but perfectly good rules can be undermined by the manner and timeliness of their enforcement.

We have seen the intervention of armchair referees go beyond the ruin of fair play in how a tournament should be conducted. We have seen it threaten the credibility of the game in the eyes of fans who can’t fathom the stupidity of a sport that cannot separate common-sense enforcement from absolute devotion to the letter of the law.

In other sports, video review’s timely use helps officials get it right. In golf, video review too often makes it feel like the sport is getting it wrong, because timeliness matters in the spirit of fair play, because the retroactive nature of some punishments are as egregious as the violations themselves.  

We saw that with Lexi Thompson at the ANA Inspiration this year.

Yes, she deserved a two-shot penalty for improperly marking her ball, but she didn’t deserve the two-shot penalty for signing an incorrect scorecard. She had no idea she was signing an incorrect scorecard.

We nearly saw the ruin of the U.S. Open at Oakmont last year, with Dustin Johnson’s victory clouded by the timing of a video review that left us all uncertain if the tournament was playing out under an incorrect scoreboard.

“What these protocols are put in place for, really, is to make sure there are measures to identify the facts as soon as possible, in real time, so if there is an issue to be dealt with, that it can be handled quickly and decisively,” Pagel said.

Amen again.

We have pounded the USGA for making the game more complicated and less enjoyable than it ought to be, for creating controversy where common sense should prevail, so let’s applaud executive director Mike Davis, as well as the R&A, for putting common sense in play.

Yes, this isn’t a perfect answer to handling rules violations.

There are trap doors in the protocols that we are bound to see the game stumble into, because the game is so complex, but this is more than a good faith effort to make the game better.

This is good governance.

And compared to the glacial pace of major rules change of the past, this is swift.

This is the USGA and R&A leading a charge.

We’re seeing that with the radical modernization of the Rules of Golf scheduled to take effect in 2019. We saw it with the release of Decision 34/3-10 three weeks after Thompson’s loss at the ANA, with the decision limiting video review to “reasonable judgment” and “naked eye” standards. We’re hearing it with Davis’ recent comments about the “horrible” impact distance is having on the game, leading us to wonder if the USGA is in some way gearing up to take on the golf ball.

Yes, the new video review protocols aren’t a panacea. Rules officials will still miss violations that should have been caught. There will be questions about level playing fields, about the fairness of stars getting more video review scrutiny than the rank and file. There will be questions about whether viewer complaints were relayed to rules officials.

Golf, they say, isn’t a game of perfect, and neither is rules enforcement, though these protocols make too much sense to be pilloried. They should be applauded. They should solve a lot more problems than they create.

Lexi 'applaud's USGA, R&A for rules change

By Randall MellDecember 11, 2017, 5:15 pm

Lexi Thompson’s pain may prove to be the rest of golf’s gain.

David Rickman, the R&A’s executive director of governance, acknowledged on Golf Channel’s "Morning Drive" Monday that the new protocols that will eliminate the use of TV viewer call-ins and emails to apply penalties was hastened by the controversy following Thompson’s four-shot penalty at the ANA Inspiration in early April. The new protocols also set up rules officials to monitor TV broadcasts beginning next year.

“Clearly, that case has been something of a focus point for us,” Rickman said.

Thompson reacted to the new protocols in an Instagram post.

“I applaud the USGA and the R&A for their willingness to revise the Rules of Golf to address certain unfortunate situations that have arisen several times in the game of golf,” Thompson wrote. “In my case, I am thankful no one else will have to deal with an outcome such as mine in the future.”

Thompson was penalized two shots for improperly returning her ball to its mark on a green during Saturday’s round after a viewer emailed LPGA officials during Sunday’s broadcast. She was penalized two more shots for signing an incorrect scorecard for her Saturday round. Thompson ultimately lost in a playoff to So Yeon Ryu.

The new protocols will also eliminate the additional two-shot penalty a player receives for failing to include a penalty when a player was unaware of the penalty.

Shortly after the ANA Inspiration, the USGA and R&A led the formation of a video review working group, which included the PGA Tour, LPGA, European Tour, Ladies European Tour and PGA of America.

Also, just three weeks after Thompson was hit with the four-shot penalty, the USGA and R&A released a new Rules of Golf decision decision (34-3/10) limiting video evidence in two ways:

1. If an infraction can’t be seen with the naked eye, there’s no penalty, even if video shows otherwise.

2. If a tournament committee determines that a player does “all that can be reasonably expected to make an accurate estimation or measurement” in determining a line or position to play from or to spot a ball, then there will be no penalty even if video replay later shows that to be wrong.

While the USGA and R&A said the new decision wasn’t based on Thompson’s ANA incident, LPGA players immediately began calling it the “Lexi Rule.”