Take away the $7 million purse, and the American Express Championship felt like a European tour event.
And its not much different when the World Golf Championships come to the United States. Even with the inflated prize money, its getting hard to distinguish between them and most other PGA Tour events.
Ernie Els earned $1.2 million for winning his first World Golf Championship at Mount Juliet.
Sergio Garcia got nearly $1.05 million for winning his first Byron Nelson Championship in Dallas.
Theyre like big American events, Nick Faldo said. The problem is, there are so many good events in America worth $5-to-$6 million, that to jump on a plane and fly here for $7 million is whoop-dee-doo. Its almost like they need to make these $15 million to get everyones attention.
It didnt help when six players from the top 50 decided not to play for a variety of reasons, most of them sound.
Nick Price stayed home because Hurricane Jeanne was on its way as his family was still recovering from Frances. Vijay Singh checked out when he found his Florida home without power from the hurricane (several players figured it was the Fijian who was out of gas from winning so much).
Phil Mickelson pulled out for personal reasons, although hes playing this week in Las Vegas.
Something needs to be done to resurrect the World Golf Championships, which just finished their sixth official season and already have become stale.
We just have a few issues that need to be corrected, PGA Tour commissioner Tim Finchem said.
Money isnt the answer, although an argument can be made.
When the World Golf Championships began in 1999, the prize money was $5 million with $1 million going to the winner, the only seven-figure payoff at an official tournament. The only events that offered more than $3 million in prize money were the majors, The Players Championship and the Tour Championship.
Now, there are 25 tournaments worth at least $5 million, and 11 players already have cashed checks worth at least $1 million (with one more to go at the Tour Championship).
Why go to Ireland for a chance to win $1.2 million when a player can almost get that much in Dallas?
I honestly dont think money is the factor that will drive intensity, Finchem said. Its what players hear about the tournaments, how fans feel about them. The fans want to hear its an important tournament.
The courses havent helped.
A year ago, the American Express was played somewhere north of Atlanta, south of Tennessee and so far in the middle of nowhere that watching for the blimp was the easiest way to find Capital City Club. Mount Juliet is hidden in southeastern Ireland, two hours from both Dublin and Galway.
Finchem has reason to be optimistic.
It will be held at Harding Park in San Francisco next year, and outside London at The Grove in 2006. Those are cities that can get enthused about any golf, let alone one that brings together (most of) the worlds best players.
Finchem also says he would like to get back to Bellerive in St. Louis, which was shaping up as the grandest of WGC events until the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks canceled the tournament.
If youre going to try to make this stand out in the fall, everything has to be a hit, Finchem said. You have to have a golf course everyone is excited about. There needs to be some intensity, not just competitively, but also in terms of the feel of the event.
Creating a buzz is no small task, and Finchem can only hope it helps.
Since the commissioner is accused of stealing the idea of a World Golf Championship from Greg Norman, perhaps he should go back to the Sharks original concept of small fields for only the elite players.
The NEC Invitational at Firestone began as a tournament for only Ryder Cup and Presidents Cup players. When too many players complained they were being left out, the NEC added the top 50 in the world ranking and certain tournament winners, nearly doubling the size of the field.
Im a big believer that the best players in the world have to get some perks. I believed that even when I wasnt in the NEC, said Brad Faxon, who last played in a cup in 1997. Too many players complained about it. Well, tough luck.
The only thing that has helped the WGC is the quality of winners ' Tiger Woods in eight of the 16 he has played, Darren Clarke twice, Mike Weir, Els, Stewart Cink after being picked for the Ryder Cup team, and a collection of lower-ranked players at Match Play, a product of the fickle format.
One suggestion was to devise a points system from WGC events and crown a world champion at the end of year.
That would be making something up, Faxon said. And thats still not going to get Phil here, is it?
Copyright 2004 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.