More Perry Yay or nay

RSS

The Comebacker is back after a weeks vacation in which he was reminded that he should thank his lucky stars that playing golf isnt his day job.
 
The No. 1 topic from the E-mailers is still Kenny Perry. By a long shot.
 
Without further ado:
 
Meg writes: After playing a links-style course in 20-30 mph winds yesterday, I can wholly understand anyone that opts out of that kind of frustration for the relative calm and old-style familiarity of Brown Deer GC. Besides, Kopp's Custard is just down the road and Miller has reintroduced the old formula of Schlitz beer. Yup, I'd go to Milwaukee too.
 
The Comebacker
All good reasons to skip Birkdale for Milwaukee. But not why Perry didnt go to the Open Championship.

 

John writes: I dont always agree with you but this time you are right on the money. Someone should applaud Ken Perry and say that its nice to see someone put the Ryder Cup (team specific) ahead of other things. I know this was his goal. So why is everyone harping on him. I listened to your buddy Hawkins talk the other night and since when does Perry need Hawkins blessing. He said that he had a problem with Perry opting not to go to the British Open. There are a lot of people who have a problem with Hawkins.
 
The Comebacker
John Hawkins of Golf World is the Angry Golfer. If there arent people who have a problem with him, then hes not doing his job. It reminds of the great Dan Jenkins line when a tournament official told him he had a problem with Jenkins. No, Jenkins is said to have replied, youve got a problem. Ive got a typewriter.

 

Ron writes: Kenny still has quite a ways to go for POY in my humble opinion. He will not only have to equal or simply surpass Tiger in number of wins, he'll should/need to add quality. Winning events like the John Deere, looking at the strength of field, simply adds to the win total. Piling up wins on one-off weeks (Loch Lomond had a much stronger field), and say, for example, to win this coming week in Milwaukee, does not add up to much. I'm not overlooking the Memorial win (in terms of strength of field), but he still has some distance to go for POY honors.
 
The Comebacker
Just saying its a two man race right now for Player of the Year.

 

Mike writes: Kenny Perry may be a hero in your mind but by setting up a game plan in the beginning of the year to skip the U.S. Open and the British Open tells me he is content to be a good golfer earning a living rather than being recognized as a great golfer who has tested himself against the best in golfs toughest arenas. By skipping two major tournaments, Kenny is announcing his limitations and saying I am not good enough to compete. I made the Ryder Cup by winning one semi-A tournament and two B-level tournaments. Golf heroes test themselves against the best and they never pass up the opportunity to compete for golfs greatest honors. For you then, a golf hero should be redefined as someone who thrives on playing it safe.
 
The Comebacker
For me a golf hero is a terrific player who considers the life he leads away from the golf course to be more important than the score he shoots on it. Kenny Perry qualifies easily under those criteria.

 

Bradford writes: The John Deere Classic was just another example of what the Tour looks like without Tiger. The top 20 golfers after Saturday averaged OVER PAR on Sunday. Without Tiger in the field, the formula for winning is: get in contention, shoot par on Sunday and watch everyone else self-destruct. The purses are so large, they dont need to deliver under pressure on Sunday to take home a big check.
 
The Comebacker
Not everyone self-destructed.

 

Fred writes:The only thing I needed to hear from Kenny Perry about not flying across the Atlantic for the worlds oldest championship was that he had committed to play in Milwaukee prior to qualifying for the Open. If nothing else, the British understand the importance of keeping ones word. Something it seems the good people of our country seem on the verge of forgetting way too often. Some of us still feel that being a considered a gentleman means more than doffing your cap to an appreciative crowd.
 
The Comebacker
Amen.

 

Willy writes:How could you even mention that Kenny Perry is up for Player of the Year? All his wins mostly are from weak field and somewhat 2nd tier tournaments. Your golf comments are so ridiculous! Perry also loves to have Milwaukee beers the rest of his life..not the Claret Jug with no beers. Uug.
 
The Comebacker
The Memorial was a strong field. And there is no such thing as an easy win on the PGA TOUR. Too many good players from top to bottom.

 

Dana writes:I loved the article Making a Race of It and how Kenny Perry has stood up to the criticism that has been sent his way. Kenny should be commended by the media for sticking to his commitments and being a man of integrity. He has clearly stated all season what his goal was and has adamantly stuck by his plan. Many other golfers would have jumped at the chance to play in the Open Championship and easily dismissed a prior commitment to the Milwaukee tournament. I have always been impressed with Kenny, but this simple act of making a commitment and sticking to it shows me and everyone else what type of person he is. With all the recent talk and columns regarding role models in golf, one need look no further than Kenny Perry. Kenny has definitely earned another measure of respect from this fan and I hope for one to see a 4-0-0 performance in Valhalla as a just reward for his actions.
 
The Comebacker
Why not 5-0-0?

 

Joseph writes:I agree with Mr. Perry's statement that he is a independent contractor and can play or not play when and where he chooses. I am also very thankful that such players as Arnold Palmer, Jack Nicklaus, Tom Watson, Lee Trevino and a large number of American players have a broader perspective of their role in not only competing but promoting the game of golf on a world wide stage. Can you imagine Jack Nicklaus stating he will not compete in his countrys Open championship because the course does not suit his game or Tiger not playing in the Open Championship because he dislikes long distance travel. No, Mr. Perry has the right to choose but thank God his playing decisions were not shared by the great American players from the last five decades of golfing history who have inspired millions and have truly grown the game of golf.
 
The Comebacker
Fair points.

 

Cliff writes: While I understand your point of view regarding Kenny Perry, I would be a little concerned that his game is not being tested at a level that represents anything near the cauldron surrounding the Ryder Cup. If he can make some, in your words Dodgy chip shots coming down the stretch at a lesser event at the John Deere, how is he likely to be prepared for the jump to a Ryder Cup without preparing himself in major competition? Coming from Europe, he's doing a great thing as far as I am concerned; I just hope he opts out of the PGA as well!
 
The Comebacker
Clearly, The Comebacker is in Perrys corner. But Captain Azinger must have winced a little in private at the two aforementioned chip shots. Guarantee you Perry wasnt very happy with them either.

 

Andrew writes:How can any tournaments, in which Tiger would have played, not be remembered throughout HISTORY, as played without Tiger, due to injury, and therefore IS less meaningful... to whatever extent each golf fan deems it. Only when Tiger is once again unseated as No. 1 and as you said, Tiger can't stay No. 1 forever, will us fans and especially all of Tiger's peers, agree that a Tiger-tournament, played in his absence, for any reason, will have a 100% deserving winner... without the question we will all have until Tiger plays again... would he have won with Tiger in the field? The question about the asterisk may have been raised, even if Tiger hadn't won the U.S. Open. But, the fact that he did, the way he did, leaves the above question begging for me, as I suspect it does for many fans.
 
The ComebackerI dont see anybody calling Geoff Ogilvy an asterisk U.S. Open champion even though Tiger Woods didnt make the cut in 2006 at Winged Foot and even though Phil Mickelson made a hash of the 72nd hole.
 

George writes: Are you kidding? What could be worse for the confidence of the U.S. Ryder cup team than having this neurotic, self-loathing, whiner on the team? Hopefully Zinger recognizes that and manages to keep him off the team. Personally I wish the Golf Channel would stop interviewing the guy; he's a terribly negative influence on golfer's swing thoughts! Please reconsider your recommendation.
 
The Comebacker
George was talking about Woody Austin. I disagree. Woody is Woody and has been proven to be a positive influence in the team room.

 

Dennis writes: Tiger should take all the time needed for a complete recovery, be it 12 or 15 months, and I mean a complete recovery. And then when he comes back, even if he has to sacrifice 20 to 30 yards on his drives, he will be deadly accurate on all his shots, let alone his putting. By God it is scary just to think about it and he might not lose a tournament until he retires. Take your time, Tiger, we will all be the better off for it! God Bless you.
 
The Comebacker
Tiger never losing again? Hadnt thought of that one.

 

Email your thoughts to Brian Hewitt