Punch Shot: One fix for the Ryder Cup

By Golf Channel DigitalSeptember 30, 2014, 12:50 pm

Everytime the U.S. team loses a Ryder Cup (especially when it loses big), panic ensues. Does the Ryder Cup need fixing? GolfChannel.com writers weigh in with what, if any, change is required to make the competition more competitive.


The Ryder Cup doesn’t need fixing. It’s the American team that needs fixing. American players expected captain Tom Watson to put them in position to look good at Gleneagles this past week. Watson expected the players to make him look good. It's embarrassing how awful they made each other look in the aftermath.

Yes, the PGA of America needs to re-examine how it chooses its captains, needs some kind of summit to come up with a system for preparing the U.S. team for Ryder Cups, some model that gives continuity to the succession of captaincy. Still, hot players hold trump cards in golf. The Americans can help themselves in that department moving the selection of captain’s picks back until the Tour Championship is complete. The FedEx Cup playoffs are a great barometer of who’s hot. It’s such a waste that the picks are made halfway through them. Really, if the Americans flipped three matches this past week, they win the cup. Billy Horschel and Chris Kirk would have brought something vital to the Ryder Cup if picked after the Tour Championship. They would have brought momentum.


The Ryder Cup isn't "broken" and doesn't need "fixing" just because one team always wins and the other, well, doesn't.

That doesn't mean, though, that after 40 editions of the event, it's totally infallible.

If I was pronounced King of the Ryder Cup (which admittedly might not happen anytime soon), I'd add a little more intrigue to the festivities - and I would steal it straight from the Presidents Cup.

The idea of random pairings based on how the captains separately order their lineups is outdated. I'd get 'em into a room before each session and match up players, fantasy draft-style. And just because I'm a benevolent king, I'd put the entire thing on live TV so everyone could watch them squirm through the decision-making process.

Unlike other potential changes, this one doesn't need a major fix in policy. But it would definitely add a new dynamic to the proceedings.


For a week Paul McGinley talked about Europe’s winning Ryder Cup template, the mystical format that produced yet another victory for the Continent in the biennial matches. When pressed for the magical “template” on Sunday, however, it was the players, not the diminutive captain, who answered.

“Wave after wave,” smiled Graeme McDowell.

“When the storm comes, we'll be the rock,” offered Justin Rose.

“Have fun,” laughed Lee Westwood.

Europe’s secret, at least the core of it, is in its captains’ ability to make the players buy into the master plan. For McGinley those concepts included avoiding complacency and not letting up, even when the team took a 10-to-6 lead into Sunday singles. For Jose Maria Olazabal in 2012 that blueprint was slightly different, but the constant is the European players’ commitment to the plan.

If the U.S. team is going to end a slide that has now been run to eight losses in its last 10 matches it will need to find a way to duplicate that concept and it starts and ends with the captain. Like the Europeans, the U.S. needs to include the players in the captain’s selection process. It is the most obvious way to get them fully invested in the process and the plan.


My one fix for the Ryder Cup? Simple – don’t hire another Tom Watson.

Seriously, the over-the-top, blow-the-system-up reaction to another American loss was entirely too predictable. Lest you forget, the 2010 Ryder Cup was decided by the final two men on the course. The U.S. would have won the 2012 matches if not for a 45-footer on 17 by Justin Rose and Ian Poulter draining, well, just about everything. More often than not, the Ryder Cup is an evenly matched, fiercely competitive event.

That Europe won this year shouldn’t have been surprising– it was playing on home soil (where it hasn’t lost since 1993) and boasted arguably its strongest team ever, with four of the top 5 players in the world. Throw in the fact that the Americans had an out-of-touch, irrational and impulsive captain in Watson, and the U.S. had virtually no chance in Scotland.

Such stinging (and public) criticism by Phil Mickelson will undoubtedly prompt change – perhaps giving players more input on future captains – but we should hope it’s not a complete overhaul of the system. In a Watson-less Ryder Cup, it’s almost always a fair fight. 


I have no issue with the format or minutiae of the event, but if the U.S. is going to restore the Ryder Cup to anything resembling a competitive contest, the powers that be must divorce from the notion that future American captains must be former major champions. Every U.S. leader dating back to 1927 has had a major victory on his resume, which makes introductory press conferences easier but does not necessarily translate into that individual’s ability to lead a squad of 12 men in a team competition.

Paul McGinley never won a major, but Sunday he became the fourth such European captain in the last 20 years to hoist the cup, joining Bernard Gallacher (1995), Sam Torrance (2002) and Colin Montgomerie (2010). While a captain’s decisions on picks and pairings can be second-guessed regardless of his credentials, there is something to be said for hiring someone for whom a victorious captaincy would serve as a career highlight. 

Getty Images

M. Jutanugarn finally joins sister in LPGA winner's circle

By Associated PressApril 23, 2018, 1:42 am

LOS ANGELES - Moriya Jutanugarn won the Hugel-JTBC L.A. Open by two shots for her first victory in six years on the LPGA Tour, joining sister Ariya as the second siblings to win on the tour.

The 23-year-old from Thailand shot a 3-under 68 for a 12-under 272 total Sunday at Wilshire Country Club in the tour's return to Los Angeles after a 13-year absence.

Jutanugarn won in her 156th start after three career runner-up finishes, including at the Honda LPGA Thailand in February. She had 21 top-10 finishes before winning.

Seven-time winner Ariya tied for 24th after a 70. She joined the predominantly Asian crowd to follow her older sister's final holes, crying as Moriya two-putted to close out the win.

Annika and Charlotta Sorenstam were the first sisters to win on the LPGA Tour.

Hall of Famer Inbee Park shot a 68 to tie for second with Jin Young Ko (70).

Park had opportunities, but she wasn't able to put pressure on Jutanugarn playing in the final threesome. However, Park will return to No. 1 in the world when the rankings come out Monday, knocking off top-ranked Shenshen Fang, who tied for 12th.

Full-field scores from the Hugel-JTBC Open

Jutanugarn began the final round with a two-shot lead and never wavered in fulfilling the potential she first displayed as the LPGA Rookie of the Year in 2013. After a birdie at the second hole, she reeled off nine consecutive pars before sinking birdie putts at 12 and 13.

She overcame a tee shot that narrowly missed going out of bounds for another birdie at 15 to lead by three.

Jutanugarn ran into trouble on the par-4 16th. Her approach landed on the green and rolled off it, stopping inches from dropping into a bunker. Her chip shot ran well past the hole and her par putt just missed catching the edge of the cup. That left her with a short putt for bogey, her first in her previous 28 holes, trimming her lead to two shots.

Ko's tee shot on 18 landed about 4 feet from the hole, giving her a chance to cut Jutanugarn's lead to one shot with the Thai facing a long birdie attempt.

But Ko missed, leaving Jutanugarn room to maneuver. Her birdie putt came up a couple feet short, but she calmly parred the hole to win. Ariya rushed onto the green and joined others in emptying water bottles on her sister before they embraced.

So Yeon Ryu (68) finished fourth at 7 under. American Emma Talley (67) and Eun-Hee Ji (71) tied for fifth at 6 under, making Ji one of four South Koreans to place in the top five.

Getty Images

After Further Review: Tour players embracing new ideas

By Golf Channel DigitalApril 23, 2018, 1:26 am

Each week, GolfChannel.com takes a look back at the week in golf. Here's what's weighing on our writers' minds.

On players embracing new ideas on the PGA Tour ...

PGA Tour players are trying to tell commissioner Jay Monahan something: They like new.

In the second year of the two-man team format at the Zurich Classic, 10 of the top 14 players in the world have signed up, including all four reigning major champions. It’s the first time all four have been in the same field since the Tour Championship. If the laid-back event offered world-ranking points – it doesn’t, and that’s part of the appeal – the winner would have received 62 points. That’s the same as the Genesis Open.

Sure, some sponsor obligations are involved in boosting the field here, but there’s no other way to look at this: Today’s PGA Tour players are not only willing to play events that are a departure from the 72-hole, stroke-play norm. They’re encouraging it. - Ryan Lavner

On Moriya Jutanugarn's breakthrough win ...

As much love as there is between the Jutanugarn sisters, it couldn’t have been easy for Moriya, watching her baby sister, Ariya, soar past her as one of the LPGA’s dominant stars the last few years. Mo, though, never betrayed an inkling of frustration or envy.

That’s what made Mo’s breakthrough LPGA victory Sunday at the Hugel-JTBC LA Open especially meaningful for everyone who has admired Mo’s devotion to her sister. Mo was always a fixture, waiting in the wings to celebrate whenever Ariya hoisted a trophy.

So emotions were high late Sunday, with Ariya waiting in the wings this time, with Ariya sobbing in Mo’s arms after the victory was secured. It was heartwarming for more than Apple, the mother who raised these talented, loving sisters. As always, Apple was there, too, soaking both her daughters in tears of joy. – Randall Mell

On the tough scheduling decisions facing the PGA Tour ...

According to multiple sources, officials at Colonial are poised to announce a new sponsorship agreement with Charles Schwab Corporation on Monday.

While this is good news for the folks in Fort Worth, Texas, who were in danger of finding themselves on the wrong side of timing, there remain some tough decisions to be made in the next few weeks.

If the PGA Tour’s plan is to end its season before Labor Day beginning in 2019, something must give. Currently, the Houston Open, a staple on Tour since 1946, and The National are without sponsors. When the music stops in a few weeks and the circuit announces the ’19 schedule, there’s a good chance one, or both, of those events will be the victims of bad timing. – Rex Hoggard

Getty Images

Triplett hole-out wins Legends of Golf playoff

By Associated PressApril 23, 2018, 12:12 am

RIDGEDALE, Mo. - Kirk Triplett holed out from a bunker for birdie on the first playoff hole Sunday in the Bass Pro Shops Legends of Golf to lift himself and partner Paul Broadhurst past Bernhard Langer and Tom Lehman.

''Well, you're trying to make it, but you know realistically it doesn't go in very often,'' Triplett said. ''You're trying to give your partner a free run at it. You don't want to hit it up there 20 feet past or do something silly. I'm just trying to hit it the right distance and get it on the right line.''

Langer and Lehman took it in stride.

''You kind of learn to expect it,'' Lehman said. ''These guys out here are so good and Kirk Triplett is a magician around the greens. The odds of making that shot are probably not good, but you certainly expect him to hit a great shot and he did and it went in.''

Lehman and Langer missed birdie putts after Triplett holed out.

''I kind of felt like we both hit pretty good putts, misread them, both of them,'' Lehman said. ''I hit mine probably too hard and Bernhard's was too soft, but you have to hand it to the guys who hit the shot when they have to hit it.''

Full-field scores from the Bass Pro Shops Legends of Golf

Broadhurst and Triplett closed with a 6-under 48 on the Top of the Rock par-3 course to match Langer and Lehman at 24 under. Langer and Lehman had a 47, playing the front nine in alternate shot and the back nine in better ball.

The 56-year-old Triplett won his sixth PGA Tour Champions title.

''That's a big roller-coaster - three good shots and mine, right?'' Triplett said. ''I'm feeling a little dejected walking down that fairway there, a little sheepish. To knock it in it just reminds you, this game, you know, crazy stuff.''

Broadhurst claimed his third senior victory.

''I don't get too emotional, but that was something special,'' the 52-year-old Englishman said.

Spanish stars Miguel Angel Jimenez and Jose Maria Olazabal had a 48 to tie for third with 2017 winners Vijay Singh and Carlos Franco. Singh and Franco, the third-round leaders, shot 50.

Mark Calcavecchia-Woody Austin (48), John Daly-Michael Allen (49), Steve Stricker-Jerry Kelly (50) and David Toms-Steve Flesch (52) tied for fifth at 20 under.

Getty Images

Mullinax (T-2) comes up short of maiden win

By Will GrayApril 23, 2018, 12:06 am

The Valero Texas Open saw an unheralded player break through to earn a maiden victory, but unfortunately for Trey Mullinax his day will have to wait.

Mullinax started the final round within a shot of the lead, having fired a course-record 62 during the final round. He trailed Andrew Landry by one shot for much of the final round while racking up six birdies over his first 11 holes, but a pair of late miscues meant the former Alabama standout had to settle for a share of second place, two shots behind Landry.

A final-round 69 marked a career-best finish for Mullinax, who is playing this season on conditional status and whose lone prior top-10 this season came after he Monday qualified for the Valspar Championship.

"I know my game's there, I'm playing really well," Mullinax told reporters. "Give all credit to Andrew, he played really well today, rocksteady. He was putting great, hitting great shots."

Full-field scores from the Valero Texas Open

Valero Texas Open: Articles, photos and videos

Given time to reflect, the 26-year-old will likely look back on the final two holes where nerves appeared to get the best of him. Looking to put some pressure on Landry, Mullinax chunked his pitch on the short 17th hole into a greenside bunker, leading to a bogey on one of the easiest holes on the course.

Then Mullinax was unable to convert a 9-foot birdie putt on the final green, which would have forced Landry to make his 8-foot par putt to avoid a playoff. Afforded the luxury of two putts for the win, Landry rolled in his par save to cement a two-shot win.

"Made a bad bogey on 17, but just you've got to hit some bad shots," Mullinax said. "Would have liked to have got the putt on 18 to fall to put a little bit of heat on him, but this experience that I'm gaining right now is just going to help me down the road."