It was about more than the new grooves on the putter face.
It wasn’t really about technology at all.
No matter what Woods says about his tinkering with a new putter, you can bet he was looking for the same thing every professional looks for when he makes a change.
“When you see a player looking for a new putter, it isn't really a new putter he's looking for,” says Hall of Fame teacher Bob Toski, the PGA Tour’s leading money winner in 1954. “He's looking for confidence, the confidence he thinks that putter can give him.”
It’s why Woods ditching his hallowed Scotty Cameron Newport 2 for a Nike Method 001 created such a fuss.
Even in the case of Woods, who ranks as one of the greatest putters who ever lived, the problem’s likely the archer and not the arrow, as pros say about putting woes.
And yet the best players the game has ever seen believe there can be magic in new arrows.
They believe it profoundly.
Jack Nicklaus wasn’t married to a putter, winning his 18 majors with four different models.
Before the ’67 U.S. Open at Baltusrol, Nicklaus was struggling with his putting and ready to abandon the Ping model he was using. He tried one of Deane Beman’s Bulls Eye putters on the practice putting green before the event and fell in love with it, but Beman didn’t want to part with it.
Could you imagine the reaction in the British tabloids if Woods had tried out putters belonging to other players on the practice green at St. Andrews last week? He would have been declared a lost soul with no chance of recovery.
Nicklaus, by the way, won at Baltusrol in ‘67 with a putter dubbed “White Fang,” an Acushnet John Reuter Jr. Bulls Eye given to him by a friend of Beman’s. Fred Mueller had a model just like Beman’s but painted the blade white to reduce the sun’s glare, thus the nickname. Nicklaus made eight birdies in the final round to win and broke Ben Hogan’s U.S. Open 72-hole scoring record.
Though Nicklaus won four other tournaments with White Fang, he would abandon the putter in search of another freshening of confidence and a more magical arrow.
Nicklaus won the ’66 Masters with a Slazenger Jack Nicklaus putter, the ’67 U.S. Open with White Fang and the ’86 Masters with a MacGregor Response ZT putter. It’s important to note he did show some unusual affection for a George Low Sportsman putter. He won 15 of his majors with that.
Losing confidence in a putter isn’t normally a big deal in golf circles. It happens every week on the PGA Tour. It happens every day. It’s just that everything’s spectacularly larger when Woods is involved.
And Woods’ Scotty Cameron Newport 2 was invested spectacularly with confidence.
Woods made that putter a big deal winning 13 major championships after putting it in his bag at the Byron Nelson Classic in 1999, winning all but one of his majors with it. He won 63 PGA Tour titles with the putter and more than $87 million in PGA Tour earnings.
That Woods is searching for his old confidence doesn’t make him desperate. It makes him a pretty typical Tour pro. But that’s big news, too. Woods has never been your typical Tour pro.
Sergio Garcia used more putters in a single round than Woods used in a 12-year run.
Garcia stuffed a belly putter and a short putter in his bag before defeating John Senden in the first round of the Accenture Match Play Championship two years ago.
When it comes to chasing confidence, Mark Calcavecchia’s a virtual playboy with putters, a classic love ‘em and leave ‘em sort of guy.
“I’ve played more than once with two putters in the same round,” Calcavecchia once told me. “I’ve used a different putter in all four rounds of a tournament before.”
And Calcavecchia’s finished more than one round without a putter in his bag.
“If I’ve got a putter that’s not working, there’s a good chance I’m going to toss it,” he said. “I can think of a half dozen that are at the bottom of lakes somewhere. I can think of a couple others that I’ve buried in flower gardens.”
When you see Woods tossing his putter in a lake, or burying it in a garden before trying out Calcavecchia’s claw grip, you’ll know he’s gone beyond chasing confidence and is truly experiencing a crisis of confidence.
You don’t have to be a student of psychoanalyst Heinz Kohut’s deep probing into how shame affects behavior to surmise that Woods’ performance is impacted by the turmoil that’s invaded his head and heart these last eight months, but you'd have to be a psychic to know if his confidence will ever fully return.
All we know right now is that he’s beginning to look like every other Tour pro. He’s chasing confidence that comes and goes.