Punch Shot: What's the scariest hole in golf?

By Jason Sobel, Ryan LavnerOctober 31, 2014, 4:40 pm

Halloween is upon us, which means costumes, trick-or-treaters, pumpkin-spiced everything and spooky stories. That got us thinking about the scariest holes in golf. Our GolfChannel.com writers weigh in:


Let’s read the fine print very carefully: It’s not asking for the “best” hole or the “toughest” hole; it’s asking for the scariest one.

My first thought went to the peninsula green at TPC Sawgrass’ 17th hole, but really, how scary is a hole that you can attack with a pitching wedge? My next thought went to the eighth hole at Pebble Beach, which Jack Nicklaus has called the “most intimidating second shot in golf,” but I still don’t know if I’d categorize it as scary.

No, for that honor we must travel to the Legend Golf and Safari Resort in South Africa, which features something called an “Extreme 19th” hole. It’s a 630-yard par-3 with a teebox 1,400 feet above the green that is only accessible by helicopter. Yes, you read that correctly: A 630-yard par-3. Photos from the tee make it look like you could fall off the edge of the earth with a clumsy swing.

I won’t admit that I’m scared of heights, but I will say that I’d rather swim from tee box to green at Sawgrass’ famous par-3, ducking the gators in that water, rather than take my chances 1,400 feet above the ground.


One of the great thrills of my otherwise ordinary golfing life was playing Augusta National the day after the 2012 Masters. Playing from the member tees but firing to the same hole locations as Bubba and Co. on Sunday, I grappled with many of the same tough questions: Why is it so difficult to breathe on the first tee? Is triple a good score on 11? Am I going to pinball this tee shot on 18?

And the most obvious question: What the heck am I going to do on 12?

Bar none, it’s the scariest hole in golf – 150 yards of pure terror, from the precision required on the tee shot to the deft touch on the greens.

The first player in our group caught a gust of wind, his ball hitting the bank short of the green and kicking back into Rae’s Creek. Double. The second guy flushed his shot over the back of the green, onto a downslope near the bunker, a spot so dead it might as well have come with a body bag. Triple.

Somehow, I sent a pitching wedge to the back of the green (and two-putted for par!), and there is no moment in golf quite like watching that tee shot fly through the air for what seems like an eternity. The nausea subsides eventually – just in time for the walk across the famed Hogan Bridge.


I don’t think it gets much scarier than the 16th hole at Cypress Point.

It combines all the factors that can make a player weak in the knees: long par-3, small margin for error, and, oh yeah, water. As in, the Pacific Ocean.

With winds whipping off the coastline and waves crashing at a player’s feet on the tee, the hazard separating green from tee can make it seem like you’re trying to hit Alcatraz from the Golden Gate Bridge. The cliffs also wrap around the back left of the green, just in case you thought there might be any semblance of a viable bailout area.

No. 16 at Cypress is also often discussed as one of the most scenic holes in all of golf, but as any married man can attest, sometimes beauty and fear can go hand-in-hand. 


The 12th hole at Augusta National may be the most mercurial in all of golf. That’s why it’s the scariest. That pocket of Amen Corner seems to have its own climate, and it drives players nuts. You’ve seen how club selection befuddles them, how it can be such maddening guesswork, with players scratching their heads seeing the flag on the 11th green blowing in one direction and the flag on the 12th green blowing in the opposite direction.

It’s a scary hole because invisible forces can inflict so much pain on perfectly good shots. A good swing, a flush strike, can be batted down into Rae’s Creek, or pushed into the azaleas, or whisked into trouble over the green. The fear is in the helplessness felt with a ball on its way to god knows what. 


While the line between what makes a golf hole demanding as opposed to scary is in the eye of the beholder, there are a few elements that clarify the transition.

Visual intimidation, a steep cost for lack of execution and proximity to the finish line all factor into the equation, and the 17th hole at the Old Course in St. Andrews, Scotland, has it all.

There may be more difficult tee shots in the game, but there is no more intimidating phrase in golf than, “Just aim at the ‘O’ in the Old Course Hotel sign.” The drive at the penultimate hole must begin out of bounds and aimed precisely at a wall that towers some three stories high.

If, and that’s a big if considering the width of the fairway, your drive safely finds the short grass and not, say, the Jigger Inn which looms just to the right of the hole, that’s when things really get scary.

Depending on the wind, players will have a mid- to short-iron into a narrow green with a road and a wall waiting if you go long. And the infamous Road Hole bunker – where many solid rounds have gone to die (see Duval, David, 2000 Open Championship) – awaits for those unfortunate enough to come up short.

It may not be the toughest hole in major championship golf, but it’s certainly the scariest.

Getty Images

Bubba thinks he'll need a Sunday 60 to scare Casey

By Will GrayJune 23, 2018, 11:15 pm

CROMWELL, Conn. – Perhaps moreso than at most PGA Tour venues, a low score is never really out of reach at TPC River Highlands. Positioned as a welcome change of pace after the U.S. Open, the Travelers Championship offers a lush layout that often pushes the balance much closer to reward than risk.

This is where Jim Furyk shot a 58 on the par-70 layout two years ago – and he didn’t even win that week. So even though Paul Casey enters the final round with a commanding four-shot lead, there’s still plenty of hope for the chase pack that something special could be in store.

Count Bubba Watson among the group who still believe the title is up for grabs – even if it might require a Herculean effort, even by his standards.

Full-field scores from the Travelers Championship

Travelers Championship: Articles, photos and videos

Watson has won the Travelers twice, including in a 2015 playoff over Casey. But starting the final round in a large tie for sixth at 10 under, six shots behind Casey, he estimates that he’ll need to flirt with golf’s magic number to give the Englishman something to worry about.

“My 7 under yesterday, I need to do better than that. I’m going to have to get to like 10 [under],” Watson said. “The only beauty is, getting out in front, you have a chance to put a number up and maybe scare them. But to scare them, you’re going to have to shoot 10 under at worst, where I’m at anyway.”

Watson started the third round three shots off the lead, and he made an early move with birdies on Nos. 1 and 2 en route to an outward 32. The southpaw couldn’t sustain that momentum, as bogeys on Nos. 16 and 17 turned a potential 65 into a relatively disappointing 67.

“Bad decision on the par-3, and then a very tough tee shot for me on 17, and it just creeped into the bunker,” Watson said. “Just, that’s golf. You have mistakes every once in a while.”

Getty Images

Day (66) only star to shine Saturday at Travelers

By Will GrayJune 23, 2018, 11:01 pm

CROMWELL, Conn. – With an early rain softening an already vulnerable course, there were plenty of birdies to be had during the third round of the Travelers Championship. They were few and far between, however, for some of the biggest names in the field.

On the same TPC River Highlands layout where Paul Casey took control of the tournament with an 8-under 62, the decorated quartet of Jordan Spieth, Rory McIlroy, Justin Thomas and Brooks Koepka combined to shoot 1 under with no single score better than a 1-under 69.

Spieth’s dim hopes of back-to-back titles were effectively ended with a 1-over 71, while McIlroy’s second straight 69 dropped him from three shots off the lead to outside the top 10.

Full-field scores from the Travelers Championship

Travelers Championship: Articles, photos and videos

Thomas (70) and Koepka (69) are now 11 and 12 shots back, respectively.

Among the top-ranked contenders, the only player to make a modicum of a move was Jason Day, who shot a 4-under 66 and heads into the final round in a tie for sixth, six shots behind Casey. The Aussie made four birdies over his first nine holes, but he stalled out on the more gettable inward half.

“I’m happy with the way I’m playing right now. I played well today from tee to green,” Day said. “Tomorrow it all depends on how Paul plays.”

Day has won twice already this season, but facing a significant deficit against a seasoned veteran he realizes that a quick start will be necessary to retain any hopes for a third title.

“This course can yield some birdies, which is quite nice,” Day said. “Get through tomorrow in a couple under on the front side, and then try to let things go a little bit on the back side if you can.”

Getty Images

Monkey off his back, Casey freed up to win again

By Will GrayJune 23, 2018, 10:49 pm

CROMWELL, Conn. – Paul Casey is flushing his irons, rolling in putts and no longer fielding questions about a lengthy victory drought. For the remaining players looking to chase him down at the Travelers Championship, it adds up to a terrifying combination.

The Englishman felt right at home on a gray and dreary afternoon at TPC River Highlands, vaulting to the top of the leaderboard with an 8-under 62. It was the lowest round of the week, two shots better than the next best effort Saturday, and it turned a two-shot deficit into a four-shot lead heading into the final round.

After enduring an afternoon logjam, with as many as five players sharing the lead at one point, the tournament is now Casey’s to lose – and he’s not shying away from the burden.

“You’d always rather have a lead,” Casey said. “When you’re behind, there is no room for error. No, I’m excited. I’ve got confidence in my game. I’ve got confidence with the man standing next to me (caddie John McLaren), confidence in the gameplan of how to get around this golf course.”

That approach is undoubtedly aided by the magic act Casey pulled off in March at the Valspar Championship. Teeing off well before the tournament leaders, he shot a final-round 65 and watched as the likes of Tiger Woods and Patrick Reed were unable to match his number.

Without having to field a single question about the weight of the burden he shouldered, about ending a PGA Tour victory drought that extended back to the 2009 Houston Open, Casey launched the monkey off his back and into the trees lining the 18th fairway at Innisbrook.

While Casey has won 13 times on the European Tour, including five times from 2009-14, his dry spell on this side of the Atlantic had become a point of discussion and one that wore on the affable veteran. But one sublime round in Tampa rendered it moot, and it will also grant him an extra sense of calm heading into the final round outside Hartford where only Russell Henley will start the day within five shots of his total.

“If I hadn’t won in a while, then yeah, there would be more pressure. I sit here right now with no nerves,” Casey said. “I’m sure there will be tomorrow, but no nerves now. I’m very happy with what I’ve done. In years past maybe that wouldn’t have been the case because there hadn’t been enough wins.”

Full-field scores from the Travelers Championship

Travelers Championship: Articles, photos and videos

Granted, this is an event that often doesn’t follow the script. Birdies will be there for the taking on a course softened by light rains, and low scores shouldn’t be hard to find. This is, after all, where Jim Furyk shot a 58 two years ago and where Kevin Streelman ended his comeback victory in 2014 with a run of seven straight birdies.

Trailing by six, Bubba Watson floated the notion of needing a 60 to catch Casey without any hint that the score is out of reach. Jason Day, who like Watson trails by six at 10 under, quickly sniffed out Casey’s long-term track record like a shark seizing on a droplet of blood.

“Tomorrow it all depends on how Paul plays,” Day said. “I know that he in the past hasn’t quite got over the line with some of the wins that he possibly could have won, and that’s kind of a positive in my mind knowing that.”

But the look of calm confidence that emanates from Casey is that of a man who no longer has to answer questions about when The Win will come. His next victory will be just that, the next one. Another trophy to add to the decorated credentials of a player who has re-established himself in the game’s upper echelon over the past three years.

He’s back on a course he has thrived on from the very first time he set foot on the property, losing in a playoff to Watson in 2015 in his tournament debut. He has returned each year since, finishing T-17 and T-5.

His final-round 71 in 2016, carded the same day Furyk shot his 58, is proving more and more to be an aberration since each of his other 14 competitive rounds in Cromwell have ended up in the 60s. That includes three straight this week, capped by Saturday’s effort where he hit every green in regulation and tied his career low score on Tour.

Yes, the tournament is Casey’s to lose. But liberated by a recent win and playing some of his best golf at one of his favorite venues, there’s little reason to expect him to do anything but lift the trophy he barely missed out on three years ago.

“If I go out there tomorrow and I hit it the way I normally hit it, and I putt it well,” Casey said, “then I’m fairly confident.”

Getty Images

Couples one behind Toledo; Sticker struggles in Wisc.

By Associated PressJune 23, 2018, 9:51 pm

MADISON, Wis. – Esteban Toledo birdied four of the last six holes for a 6-under 66 and the second-round lead Saturday in the American Family Insurance Championship.

Five strokes behind tournament host Steve Stricker after an opening 69 in rain Friday at University Ridge, Toledo had six birdies in a bogey-free round to reach 9-under 135. The 55-year-old Mexican player won the last of his four PGA Tour Champions titles in 2016.

Defending champion Fred Couples (67), David Toms (66), Kent Jones (67) and Billy Mayfair (68) were a stroke back.

''I'm surprised that someone isn't 11 or 12 under, but the greens picked up a lot of pace today,'' Couples said. ''I think maybe the scoring was a little easier yesterday because we got to clean the ball in the fairways, but it's not easy out there.''

Bernhard Langer (69) was 8 under with Madison player Jerry Kelly (69), Scott McCarron (67), Mark Calcavecchia (68), Paul Goydos (68), Joey Sindelar (68), Glen Day (69) and Brad Bryant (72).

Full-field scores from the American Family Insurance Championship

''The conditions haven't been that easy,'' Kelly said. ''The pins are in some spots where you can't spin it and you have to hit them firm out of these kind of soft fairways, otherwise you could chunk it. It's not that easy even though the course is gettable. There's just a few things going on out there to keep the scoring from going too low like it normally does.''

Stricker followed his opening 64 with a 74, ending his Champions under-par streak at 30 rounds - the fourth-longest streak in tour history.

''It just was one of those days where I didn't have a lot of energy,'' Stricker said. ''Nothing - hit very few good shots, really. The couple that I did hit well, I was in bad spots, and a couple bad shots even got worse.''

He had three bogeys and a birdie - on the final hole.

''That was a big birdie in my mind,'' Stricker said. ''It kept me a little bit closer. No one ran away with this thing today and three shots back, a lot of guys in between me and the lead. It was a good putt to make and finally get a birdie. That was my only one today.''

Stricker won in Arizona and Mississippi in consecutive starts in May for his first senior victories. The 12-time PGA Tour winner played the big tour the last two weeks, tying for 18th in Memphis and tying for 20th in the U.S. Open.

John Daly matched Stricker at 6 under with a 70.